By: Nicholas Cejas / Contributing Writer
With the Supreme Court currently deciding upon the fate of the Obama-era policy Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, student-run organization Federalist Society (FedSoc) hosted What’s Next for DACA at the FIU College of Law on March 4 to discuss the controversy behind this program.
Professor Josh Blackman, Associate Professor of Law at the South Texas College of Law, and Professor Juan Gomez, Director of the Carlos A. Costs Immigration and Human Rights Clinic at FIU College of Law, debated upon the legalities of the DACA program.
Professor Blackman began by providing the backstory of the program and how it ended up in the situation it is.
“President Obama announced he would take executive action to give relief to the dreamers and announced a policy called DACA, it was not amnesty, DACA did not give citizenship, it gave them lawful presence,” said Blackman.
This lawful presence allowed recipients to work, go to school, or even get a driver’s license and more.
According to Professor Blackman, Donald Trump chose to abolish it because the Texas State threatened to sue Trump if he did not wind down the policy. Trump took the opportunity to fulfill a campaign promise without taking the heat for it and began the process of tearing down DACA.
Professor Blackman continued by addressing the questions the Supreme Court was faced with, “The Supreme Court has a couple of things to consider. First, was the decision to rescind DACA supported with the correct reasons,” he said.
There is no question whether the Trump administration is allowed to revoke it, but that there are sufficient reasons for its abolishment.
Professor Blackman explained his self admittedly unpopular position saying.
“This is where I think DACA goes too far,” he said.
According to him, Obama did not have the constitutional power to enact a program of such scale and weight as this one in an executive order.
Professor Gomez portrayed the underlying issue of DACA.
“You have people in the DACA situation where one side wants too much and the other side wants to create as many obstacles as possible including absurd things such as qualifying the parents of the DREAMERS as smugglers because they allowed the child to remain in America,” said Gomez.
This idea of “us versus them” emerged as the leading cause of the controversy on the issue. He, later on, he admitted his doubts saying: “I do believe, sadly that there will be a negative decision in the Supreme Court.”
Put simply, neither speaker was in support of sending hundreds of thousands of DACA recipients back to their home countries. Especially considering that many of these children have no ties to their country other than their heritage – but rather, to re-evaluate and reform the details and scale of the order.
Whether that be done by a supreme court ruling or a new executive order, massive amounts of young people’s lives are being affected by this decision and are something to be carefully considered.
“We have a problem that we need to address… I really do believe we are the place to come to for safety, we are the place to come to for hope, and it’s not going to stop… if your child’s life was in danger, what would you do for them?” said Gomez.